Baptist Militia A library & museum of the Whole Armour of God Visit
Find

Hall III · The Timeline

The Seventeenth Century

Page 4 of 4 · 1686 to 1691

“But the word of the Lord endureth for ever. And this is the word which by the gospel is preached unto you.”1 Peter 1:25, KJV

How the Scriptures were received, carried into the English tongue, and confessed by the Baptist churches. Each date is linked to its source, so that you may test every word.

  • Scripture & Canon (6)
  • The English Bible (4)
  • Baptist Witness (54)
  1. The Seventeenth Century1600-1699

    Baptist Witness Dissent & Persecution

    Elias Keach and Pennepek: a pretender, then a pastor

    The church’s own history says that Elias Keach arrived in Pennsylvania in 1686 as “a twenty-year old young man in whose suitcase was a black robe and a white band.” Morgan Edwards, the early Baptist historian, wrote that he “arrived in this country a very wild spark about the year 1686” and that “on his landing he dressed in black and wore a band in order to pass for a minister.” Preaching to a gathering of Welsh settlers, he “performed well enough till he had advanced pretty far in the sermon. Then, stopping short, looked like a man astonished.” He confessed the imposture “with tears in his eyes and much trembling,” and Edwards adds, “from this time dated he his conversion.” He was baptized and ordained by the Baptist minister Thomas Dungan of Cold Spring, Bucks County, and then, in Edwards’s words, “came to Pennepek and settled a church there.” The church’s history gives 1688 for its founding, calling it the eighth Baptist church begun in America, and in 1707 Pennepack joined four others in forming the Philadelphia Baptist Association. Edwards records that Keach and his family sailed for England in the spring of 1692. The apostle’s words fit such a turning: “This is a faithful saying, and worthy of all acceptation, that Christ Jesus came into the world to save sinners; of whom I am chief” (1 Timothy 1:15). The church and Edwards agree on the outline. No licence-verified plate has yet been found, so none is shown.

    Source pennepackbaptist.org: Pennepack Baptist Church, own history page (1686 arrival, imposture, Dungan, 1688 founding, eighth Baptist church in America, 1707 association); Morgan Edwards, account of Elias Keach, Baptist History Homepage baptisthistoryhomepage.com/keach.watts.morgan.by.edwards.html (c. 1686, conversion, baptized and ordained, Pennepek, 1692 departure; quoted); KJV 1 Tim 1:15 (bible-api.com).

  2. Baptist Witness Baptists in America

    Judge John Holme, a Baptist on Penn’s Bench, Stands for Conscience and the Press, 1690

    “I will speak of thy testimonies also before kings, and will not be ashamed” (Psalm 119:46). Cathcart’s Encyclopedia says John Holme of Philadelphia “is supposed to have been the first Baptist, of any prominence at least, in the colony.” He “gave one-half of the lot on which the First Baptist meeting-house was erected,” and “John Holme was appointed justice in the County Court in 1690; and he represented the city of Philadelphia in the Assembly of 1692.” Sitting with six Quaker judges at the trials of George Keith and of William Bradford, the colony’s first printer, he dissented: “Mr. Holme maintained that the whole affair was essentially a religious dispute,” and “was not fit to be adjudicated by a civil tribunal.” Cathcart adds that he “persistently dissented from the majority of the bench, and it is said actually resigned his office rather than seem to be made a party in any degree to what he regarded a case of religious persecution, and of the infringement of the liberty of the press.” He died a judge at Salem, New Jersey, in 1703, “one of the constituent members of the Baptist church in Salem.”

    Source archive.org: William Cathcart (ed.), The Baptist Encyclopedia (Philadelphia: Everts, 1881), vol. 1, s.v. “Holme, Judge John” (public domain; Internet Archive scan). Quotations verbatim, contiguous fragments only, machine-matched against the scan’s text (OCR line-end hyphenation normalised). KJV: Psalm 119:46.

  3. Baptist Witness Baptists in America

    Keithian Quaker Baptists: A Quaker Division in Pennsylvania Sends Many into Baptist Churches, 1691

    “Search the scriptures; for in them ye think ye have eternal life: and they are they which testify of me” (John 5:39). Cathcart’s Encyclopedia says that in the early history of William Penn’s colony a controversy broke out among the Quakers about “the sufficiency of what every man naturally has within himself for the purpose of his own salvation.” Some denied this sufficiency and “exalted Christ and the Scriptures” more than Robert Barclay had done. George Keith, “an impetuous and talented Scotchman,” led them, and “in 1691 it led to a division and the establishment of separate meetings in Pennsylvania and New Jersey.” Keith himself “soon turned Episcopalian”, but “many became Baptists, Seventh-Day and Regular.” They were called Quaker Baptists “because they retained the language, dress, and manners of the Quakers.”

    Source archive.org: William Cathcart (ed.), The Baptist Encyclopedia (Philadelphia: Everts, 1881), vol. 1, s.v. “Keithian Quaker Baptists” (public domain; Internet Archive scan). Quotations verbatim, contiguous fragments only, machine-matched against the scan’s text (OCR line-end hyphenation normalised; OCR misreadings corrected only outside quotation marks). KJV: John 5:39.

  4. Baptist Witness Dissent & Persecution

    Benjamin Keach Publishes Spiritual Melody: Hymns for the Congregation

    The Apostle bids believers go on “Speaking to yourselves in psalms and hymns and spiritual songs, singing and making melody in your heart to the Lord” (Ephesians 5:19), and “teaching and admonishing one another in psalms and hymns and spiritual songs, singing with grace in your hearts to the Lord” (Colossians 3:16). In 1691 Benjamin Keach, pastor at Horsleydown, Southwark, printed a book of hymns for his people: the Dictionary of National Biography lists “Spiritual Melody … Psalms and Hymns from the Old and New Testament” (1691, “nearly three hundred pieces”) and, the next year, “A Feast of Fat Things … Spiritual Songs” (1692, “one hundred pieces”). The same article says his church is “said to have been the first baptist church which introduced (about 1688) the practice of conjoint singing”, that the London General Baptist association condemned it in 1689 as a “carnal formality”, and that Keach’s advocacy of congregational singing and his issue of “a collection of original hymns (1691), caused a rupture in his church.” Wikipedia adds that the hymnbook “provoked heated debate” at the 1692 Assembly of Particular Baptists because it conflicted with the position of exclusive psalmody, and dates an earlier secession over congregational singing to 1673; the sources do not agree on the first dates, so this page gives both. What the dispute turned on was how Scripture’s own commands about singing were to be obeyed together, and Baptists went on to sing: John Rippon’s Selection (1787) is on this timeline.

    Source en.wikisource.org: Dictionary of National Biography vol. 30 (1892, public domain), “Keach, Benjamin” (Wikisource), quoted verbatim; cross-check Wikipedia “Benjamin Keach” (1692 Assembly; exclusive psalmody; 1673 secession). Dates of first congregational singing differ between sources; both are given. KJV: Eph 5:19; Col 3:16.

Plates are hung only where a genuine image of the subject could be found under a public-domain or open licence. Each carries its credit and links to its licence record. Entries without a plate are awaiting one that meets that standard. More entries are being prepared, and each will be added only with its citation.

Provenance

Every entry in this hall was checked, when it was added, against the source linked beneath it; notes name the underlying scholarship where the source cites it. Where historians disagree (for example, over John Wycliffe’s own share in the Bible that bears his name), the entry says so. Scripture is quoted verbatim from the King James Version. Plates are reproduced almost entirely from Wikimedia Commons: public-domain works, works dedicated to the public domain (CC0), or photographs under Creative Commons Attribution (CC BY 2.0-3.0) or Attribution-ShareAlike (CC BY-SA 2.0-4.0) licences. Each plate’s licence is stated beneath it, with a link to the record where it was confirmed.