Baptist Witness
The church’s own history says that Elias Keach arrived in Pennsylvania in 1686 as “a twenty-year old young man in whose suitcase was a black robe and a white band.” Morgan Edwards, the early Baptist historian, wrote that he “arrived in this country a very wild spark about the year 1686” and that “on his landing he dressed in black and wore a band in order to pass for a minister.” Preaching to a gathering of Welsh settlers, he “performed well enough till he had advanced pretty far in the sermon. Then, stopping short, looked like a man astonished.” He confessed the imposture “with tears in his eyes and much trembling,” and Edwards adds, “from this time dated he his conversion.” He was baptized and ordained by the Baptist minister Thomas Dungan of Cold Spring, Bucks County, and then, in Edwards’s words, “came to Pennepek and settled a church there.” The church’s history gives 1688 for its founding, calling it the eighth Baptist church begun in America, and in 1707 Pennepack joined four others in forming the Philadelphia Baptist Association. Edwards records that Keach and his family sailed for England in the spring of 1692. The apostle’s words fit such a turning: “This is a faithful saying, and worthy of all acceptation, that Christ Jesus came into the world to save sinners; of whom I am chief” (1 Timothy 1:15). The church and Edwards agree on the outline. No licence-verified plate has yet been found, so none is shown.
Source pennepackbaptist.org: Pennepack Baptist Church, own history page (1686 arrival, imposture, Dungan, 1688 founding, eighth Baptist church in America, 1707 association); Morgan Edwards, account of Elias Keach, Baptist History Homepage baptisthistoryhomepage.com/keach.watts.morgan.by.edwards.html (c. 1686, conversion, baptized and ordained, Pennepek, 1692 departure; quoted); KJV 1 Tim 1:15 (bible-api.com).