Baptist Witness
“Buried with him in baptism” (Colossians 2:12). Dr. John Lightfoot, a Presbyterian member of the Westminster Assembly, kept a journal of its debates, and Cathcart quotes his entry for Aug. 7, 1644: “And here fell we upon a large and long discourse, whether dipping were essential, or used in the first institution, or in the Jews’ custom.” The proposed Directory for public worship read, “The minister shall take water and sprinkle or pour it with his hand upon the face or forehead of the child,” and the count came out “the twenty-four for the reserving of dipping and the twenty-five against it.” Lightfoot wrote: “And there grew a great heat upon it; and when we had done all, we concluded upon nothing in it; but the business was recommitted.” Cathcart adds: “The next day dipping was effectually voted down as one of the modes of baptism in the Presbyterian Church.”
Source archive.org: William Cathcart (ed.), The Baptist Encyclopedia (Philadelphia: Everts, 1881), vol. 1, s.v. “Dipping in the Westminster Assembly of Divines” and “Immersion” (public domain; Internet Archive scan). Quotations verbatim, contiguous fragments only, machine-matched against the scan’s text (OCR line-end hyphenation normalised). KJV: Colossians 2:12.