Baptist Witness
“Therefore we are buried with him by baptism into death” (Romans 6:4). In his article on immersion, Cathcart records that “in 1876, Rev. J. H. Clark, of the Lackawanna Presbytery, Pa., immersed an applicant for membership in his church, for which he was censured by his Presbytery.” Clark appealed to the Synod of Philadelphia. The Synod judged that his baptism “came within the possible limits of a permissible administration of the rite” and “did not involve a moral wrong.” But since the mode was not the one the Presbyterian Church had appointed, it added, “we do approve of the spirit of the exception of the Presbytery of Lackawanna.” Cathcart set the case beside the Westminster Assembly of 1644, where many “were unwilling to have dipping excluded.”
Source archive.org: William Cathcart (ed.), The Baptist Encyclopedia (Philadelphia: Everts, 1881), vol. 1, s.v. “Immersion” (public domain; Internet Archive scan). Quotations verbatim, contiguous fragments only, machine-matched against the scan’s text (OCR line-end hyphenation normalised). KJV: Romans 6:4.