Baptist Witness
In March 1887 Spurgeon’s monthly magazine, The Sword and the Trowel, printed an unsigned article, “The Down Grade,” written by his friend Robert Shindler. It warned that some ministers were sliding away from the central doctrines of the gospel. Spurgeon took up the theme through that year. His grievances were four: denial of the infallibility of Scripture, denial of Christ’s substitutionary atonement, denial of eternal punishment, and the teaching of universalism. He put it plainly in September 1887: “We cannot hold the inspiration of the Word, and yet reject it; we cannot believe in the atonement and deny it; …” For decades he had stayed in fellowship with men who differed from him on secondary doctrines and on social and political questions. These matters of first importance were the only ones he would separate over, and in the autumn of 1887 he withdrew from the Baptist Union. On 13 January 1888 the Union’s Council passed a vote of censure, because he would not name the men he meant. In April 1888 the Assembly adopted a compromise declaration of faith. The strain told on his health, and Susannah Spurgeon later wrote that “his fight for the faith … cost him his life.” Historians still weigh the episode differently. Mark Hopkins judges that the central theological issues were never really addressed and that Spurgeon was partly to blame.
Source spurgeon.org: A. DiPrima, “What Was the Downgrade Controversy Actually All About?”, The Spurgeon Library (2022), quoting The Sword and the Trowel, September 1887, p. 465 (public domain). Shindler’s article, the censure of 13 January 1888, the April 1888 declaration and Susannah Spurgeon’s words per M. Hopkins, “The Down-Grade Controversy,” Christian History 29 (1991), christianhistoryinstitute.org. The church’s 1887 withdrawal per Metropolitan Tabernacle, “History of the Tabernacle.”
