Baptist Militia A library & museum of the Whole Armour of God Visit
Find

Hall III · The Timeline · The Early Church

The Council of Nicaea, 325, and the myth that it chose the books of the Bible

  1. Scripture & Canon

    The bishops who met at Nicaea in 325 confessed the full deity of the Son of God against Arius and framed the first form of the Nicene Creed; they also settled the date of Easter and issued church rules. A popular modern story, spread by novels such as The Da Vinci Code, says that the council, under the emperor Constantine, decided which books would be in the Bible. John D. Meade, professor at Midwestern Baptist Theological Seminary and co-director of the Text & Canon Institute, answers that there is no historical basis for it: no early record of the council and no eyewitness who attended, such as Eusebius or Athanasius, mentions any decision on the canon, and canon lists show the question discussed both before and after 325. Jerome did say the council “is read” to have counted Judith among the Scriptures, but the earliest Nicene writers, Jerome included, left Judith out of their lists. The story traces instead to a late ninth-century Greek summary, the Synodicon Vetus, printed in 1601, which tells of the true books staying on the altar while the false fell beneath it, a legend Voltaire later popularised. The churches recognised the books God gave; they did not make them. “My sheep hear my voice, and I know them, and they follow me” (John 10:27, KJV).

    Source textandcanon.org: John D. Meade, “Did Nicaea Really Create the Bible?”, Text & Canon Institute (MBTS), 2021; first at The Gospel Coalition (no basis for the claim; no council record or eyewitness (Eusebius, Athanasius) mentions it; lists disputed before and after; Jerome’s Judith preface; Synodicon Vetus, ed. Pappus 1601; Voltaire). Council’s work per Wikipedia, “First Council of Nicaea”. No plate: icons show Arius struck down. John 10:27 KJV verified.