Baptist Witness
On 24 June 1851 James Robinson Graves, editor of the Tennessee Baptist, laid five questions before a mass meeting at the Cotton Grove Baptist Church in Hardeman County, Tennessee. The first asked whether Baptists could, consistently with their principles or the Scriptures, recognise as churches of Christ those societies “not organized according to the pattern of the Jerusalem Church.” The others asked whether their ministers should be recognised as gospel ministers or invited into Baptist pulpits. The report says the discussion showed a unanimous feeling, and the queries were referred to a later meeting. Answered by refusing such recognition, they were published as the Cotton Grove Resolutions, the founding document of the Landmark movement. It took its name from J. M. Pendleton’s tract An Old Landmark Re-Set; Pendleton later turned away from most of the Landmark conclusions, while A. C. Dayton was the third of its early leaders. Graves taught that the kingdom Christ set up “in the days of John the Baptist” has never ceased from the earth, and that baptism is valid only when scripturally administered by a gospel church. Its supporters held that this was what Baptists had always believed; later scholars, among them J. L. Garrett, have called it a major departure. In 1859 the Southern Baptist Convention declined the Landmark challenge to its mission boards, and many Landmark churches in time formed their own associations. Its principles are still held in the American Baptist Association, the Baptist Missionary Association of America and some independent Baptist churches.
Source baptisthistoryhomepage.com: R. A. Baker, ed., A Baptist Source Book (1966), pp. 142-146, printing the queries from the Tennessee Baptist (1851) and J. R. Graves, Old Landmarkism: What Is It? (Memphis, 1880). Pendleton’s tract, the question of departure (J. L. Garrett, Baptist Theology, 2009), the 1859 convention and present-day bodies per Wikipedia, “Landmarkism.”
